Best Personal Accident Insurance in 2025 (Compare the Top 10 Companies)

#1 – Allstate: Top Overall Pick

Pros

• Comprehensive Coverage Options: Allstate offers a wide range of coverage options including accident forgiveness, new car replacement, and rental reimbursement.
• Strong Financial Stability: Allstate holds high ratings from financial rating agencies like A.M. Best, indicating strong financial stability.
• Discount Opportunities: They offer numerous discounts, such as safe driver discounts, multi-policy discounts, and anti-theft device discounts.

Cons

• Higher Premiums: Allstate’s premiums tend to be higher compared to other insurance providers. Consult our Allstate car insurance review for guidance.
• Mixed Customer Service Reviews: Customer service experiences can vary, with some customers reporting dissatisfaction with claim handling.

#2 – Geico: Best for Extensive Network

Pros

• Affordable Rates: Geico is known for offering some of the most competitive and affordable rates in the industry.
• Extensive Online Tools: Geico provides excellent online tools for policy management, including a highly-rated mobile app.
• Diverse Discount Options: They offer a wide range of discounts, such as for good drivers, military personnel, and federal employees.

Cons

• Limited Local Agents: Geico primarily operates online and via phone, which might not be ideal for those who prefer in-person service.
• Mixed Reviews on Claims Process: Our Geico insurance review highlights some customers have reported issues with the claims process, citing delays and communication problems.

#3 – Farmers: Best for Coverage Option

Pros

• Variety of Coverage Options: Farmers, as highlighted in our Farmers car insurance review offers a wide variety of coverage options including rideshare insurance and specialty policies.
• Customizable Policies: They allow for highly customizable policies to fit individual needs.
• Strong Agent Network: Farmers has a strong network of local agents providing personalized service.

Cons

• Higher-than-Average Rates: Farmers often has higher premiums compared to some competitors.
• Limited Online Resources: Their online tools and mobile app are not as advanced as those offered by some competitors.

#4 – Progressive: Best for Vanishing Deductible

Pros

• Competitive Pricing: Progressive is known for competitive pricing and offering discounts for bundling policies.
• Innovative Tools: They offer innovative tools like the Name Your Price tool, which helps customize policies based on budget.
• Snapshot Program: Their Snapshot program can lower premiums for safe drivers based on driving habits.

Cons

• Customer Service Issues: There are reports of inconsistent customer service experiences. Read more through our Progressive car insurance review.
• Frequent Rate Changes: Some customers have experienced frequent changes in their premium rates.

#5 – State Farm: Best for Claims Assistance

Pros

• Strong Customer Service: State Farm is well-known for excellent customer service and a vast network of agents.
• Robust Mobile App: They have a highly functional mobile app for managing policies and filing claims.
• Extensive Coverage Options: Offers a wide range of coverage options and add-ons, such as rideshare insurance and roadside assistance.

Cons

• Higher Premiums: State Farm’s premiums can be higher than those of other major insurers. Refer to our State Farm car insurance review.
• Limited Discounts: Fewer discounts compared to some other major insurance providers.

#6 – Liberty Mutual: Best for Personalized Options

Pros

• Customizable Policies: Liberty Mutual offers highly customizable policies to meet individual needs. For more information, refer to our Liberty Mutual car insurance review.
• Various Discounts: They provide numerous discounts, including for safe drivers, homeowners, and early shoppers.
• Coverage Options: Wide range of coverage options including accident forgiveness and new car replacement.

Cons

• Average Customer Satisfaction: Customer satisfaction ratings are average, with some complaints about claim handling.
• Higher Rates for High-Risk Drivers: Rates can be higher for drivers with less-than-perfect driving records.

#7 – Travelers: Best for Competitive Rates

Pros

• Competitive Rates: Travelers is known for offering competitive rates, especially for safe drivers.
• Broad Coverage Options: Our Travelers car insurance review highlights that they provide a broad range of coverage options, including gap insurance and accident forgiveness.
• Good Financial Strength: Travelers has strong financial ratings, indicating stability.

Cons

• Mixed Customer Service Reviews: Customer service reviews are mixed, with some complaints about responsiveness.
• Fewer Discounts: Travelers offers fewer discount opportunities compared to some competitors.

#8 – American Family: Best for Loyalty Discounts

Pros

• Loyalty Discounts: They offer substantial discounts for long-term customers and multi-policy holders.
• Strong Customer Service: American Family is known for strong customer service and a good network of agents.
• Flexible Coverage Options: They provide flexible coverage options tailored to individual needs.

Cons

• Limited Availability: Coverage options and discounts may vary significantly by state. Read more through our American Family car insurance review.
• Higher Premiums: Premiums can be higher compared to some national competitors.

#9 – USAA: Best for Multi-Policy Discount

Pros

• Superior Customer Satisfaction: USAA consistently ranks high in customer satisfaction surveys.
• Competitive Rates for Military Members: They offer highly competitive rates for military members and their families.
• Comprehensive Coverage Options: Offers a wide range of coverage options, including for deployed military personnel.

Cons

• Limited Eligibility: USAA is only available to military members, veterans, and their families. Read more through our USAA car insurance review.
• Limited Physical Locations: Fewer physical locations compared to other major insurers, relying heavily on online and phone service.

#10 – Nationwide: Best for Comprehensive Coverage

Pros

• Wide Range of Coverage Options: Nationwide offers a comprehensive range of coverage options including vanishing deductible and accident forgiveness.
• Strong Financial Stability: Nationwide has strong financial ratings, indicating reliability, as highlighted in our Nationwide insurance review.
• Good Discount Programs: Offers a variety of discount programs for things like safe driving, multi-policy, and smart student.

Cons

• Average Customer Service: Customer service reviews are average, with some complaints about claims processing.
• Higher Premiums: Premiums can be on the higher side compared to other major insurers.

Best Accident Insurance Companies

Several accident insurance companies offer policies to protect yourself, your family, and your finances in the event of an accident while also ensuring you meet your state’s minimum insurance requirements.

Top accident insurance companies include:

• Combined Insurance Company of America: Leading supplier of supplemental accident, disability, health, and life insurance products.
• Assurity: Offers a $250,000 death benefit and $1,250/month disability income payment for $41/month.
• Gerber: Provides $50,000 benefits for 17 cents a day, with no medical exam required.
• American Fidelity: Offers 25+ benefits covering you on or off the job.
• Mutual of Omaha: Up to $1,000,000 in coverage, including for dangerous occupations, with family coverage plans.
• Lloyd’s of London: World-famous for life insurance, rated A (excellent) by A.M. Best.
• Prudential: Highly rated (A+ by A.M. Best), offering reliable coverage.
• Sun Life: Offers benefits between $10,000 and $1 million, with some portability options.
• TruStage: Available through credit unions, with no health questionnaire or medical exam required.
• AIG/Corebridge: Provides direct purchase options with coverage starting the same day.

Accident insurance can help cover high deductibles or copays on your health insurance with a one-time payment for medical costs, ensuring you are financially protected while meeting your state’s minimum insurance requirements.

Best Car Insurance Companies With Accident Forgiveness

Hospital Indemnity Plan

Accidental Death and Dismemberment Insurance

Alternatives to the Best AD&D Insurance

Case Studies: Best Accident Insurance Companies

Introducing a series of case studies showcasing the importance of comprehensive accident insurance.

• Case Study 1 – SecureCare Accident Insurance by VitalShield: John, a professional athlete, injured his knee during a basketball game. VitalShield’s SecureCare Accident Insurance covered his medical expenses, including surgery and rehabilitation, and provided a lump sum payout for financial support during recovery.
• Case Study 2 – AccidentGuard Plus by TrustShield Insurance: Sarah, a business executive, was in a severe car accident, resulting in fractures and hospitalization. TrustShield Insurance’s AccidentGuard Plus covered her medical expenses and provided a daily cash benefit for lost income during recovery, easing financial strain for her and her family.
• Case Study 3 – AcciPro Plus by SecureLife Insurance: Tom, a construction worker, fell from a ladder, injuring his back. SecureLife Insurance’s AcciPro Plus covered his medical expenses and provided disability income, allowing him to meet financial obligations during recovery.
• Case Study 4 – Accidental Protection Plan by ShieldAssure: Emily, an adventure enthusiast, was injured during extreme sports. ShieldAssure’s Accidental Protection Plan covered her medical expenses and provided a lump sum payout for ongoing care, offering peace of mind during her recovery. When choosing accident insurance, shop around for multiple quotes to find the best coverage.