How do customer satisfaction ratings affect car insurance companies?

Car insurance satisfaction ratings are important to consider when looking for an auto insurance company. You should be careful with your research however, as some companies customer satisfaction ratings aren't legitimate.

Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

D. Gilson, PhD

Professor & Published Author

D. Gilson is a writer and author of essays, poetry, and scholarship that explore the relationship between popular culture, literature, sexuality, and memoir. His latest book is Jesus Freak, with Will Stockton, part of Bloomsbury’s 33 1/3 Series. His other books include I Will Say This Exactly One Time and Crush. His first chapbook, Catch & Release, won the 2012 Robin Becker Prize from S...

View Full Bio

Written by
D. Gilson, PhD

Joel Ohman

Certified Financial Planner

Joel Ohman is the CEO of a private equity backed digital media company. He is a CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™, author, angel investor, and serial entrepreneur who loves creating new things, whether books or businesses. He has also previously served as the founder and resident CFP® of a national insurance agency, Real Time Health Quotes. He has an MBA from the University of South Florida. Joel...

View Full Bio

Reviewed by
Joel Ohman

Updated January 2024

Here's what you need to know...

Customer satisfaction ratings are important, but you should also consider things such as price, company stability, and policy options when choosing a car insurance company
Be careful about a company’s claims of excellent customer satisfaction ratings; sometimes such claims are biased and not founded on legitimate surveys
Independent companies such as the Insurance Information Institute conduct surveys to determine if a car insurance company is doing well in various areas, including customer satisfaction
Make sure to do adequate research about all the aspects of a car insurance company before choosing one from which to buy an insurance policy

Car insurance companies often claim that customer satisfaction surveys rate their services higher than any other company. The question is: Do car insurance company customer satisfaction ratings mean anything?

The truth is that customer satisfaction ratings should have some impact on your decision to choose a particular company.

Enter your ZIP code above to compare car insurance quotes today for FREE!

The Science Behind Customer Satisfaction Ratings

The first thing that you have to understand when you hear a car insurance company sing its own praises is that unless it cites an unbiased source such as the Insurance Information Institute, J.D. Power and Associates, or other similar companies, then it isn’t talking about scientific results.

Many car insurance companies offer a survey where a computer randomly selects people who visit the car insurance company website and request that they answer a few questions for the survey.

There is no specific criteria for taking the survey, such as being male or female, an older driver versus a younger driver, a long-term customer versus a new customer, and so on.

The customer is asked a few questions on how they feel about the company and then the results are added to other results in the system.

The results are somewhat skewed because only current customers of the insurance company are asked to take the survey, which typically means that there is already a satisfied customer in the place.

In addition, these types of surveys seldom leave room for a negative opinion about the company in question.

Free Insurance Comparison

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Finding Customer Satisfaction Ratings that Count

Just because most of the surveys conducted by the car insurance companies aren’t scientific doesn’t mean that such surveys do not exist. Each year the Insurance Information Institute conducts surveys based on several criteria, including customer satisfaction.

Several entities pride themselves on providing accurate information about car insurance companies.

They typically conduct independent studies to determine if a company is doing well regarding price, products, and customer served, all from their current and former customer’s point of view.

The difference between these surveys and the ones that you see from your car insurance company is that they ask more specific questions, such as your age, gender, and where you live which helps them to determine how similar people view the insurance company.

When the results of the survey are published, all of this distinct information is provided.

The companies providing the results have no monetary interest in seeing one company come out ahead of the other.

What this means for you is that, if you see a commercial from a car insurance company stating that the III’s or the NAIC’s study shows that they are top rated in customer satisfaction, and have the best auto insurance reviews, then you should sit up and take notice.

These results are not tallied by the insurance company but by independent groups!

Criteria for Selecting a Car Insurance Company

So, should customer satisfaction ratings be taken into account when looking for the best car insurance company? Absolutely! However, you should also consider a number of other things, including:

Price
Financial stability of the company
Age of the company
Knowledge of the staff
Variety of products offered
Types of discounts offered
In which states they are available

Some of these criteria are a given, but you may be wondering why you should care in which states their insurance is available.

The truth is that if you move to another state, and you love your insurance company, but you don’t know in advance if it is available in your new state, then you could end up having to switch insurance companies.

Compare car insurance rates right now by entering your ZIP code below!

Case Studies: The Impact of Customer Satisfaction Ratings on Car Insurance Companies

Case Study 1: Stellar Insurance

Stellar Insurance boasts about its exceptional customer satisfaction ratings in its advertising campaigns. They frequently reference their top ratings in customer satisfaction from reputable organizations like the Insurance Information Institute (III) and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC).

These ratings are based on unbiased surveys conducted by independent groups, ensuring their reliability. The survey participants include customers from different demographics and regions, providing a comprehensive view of customer satisfaction.

As a result, potential customers are more likely to consider Stellar Insurance as a reliable option for their car insurance needs.

Case Study 2: Mirage Insurance

Mirage Insurance primarily relies on self-conducted surveys to determine their customer satisfaction ratings. These surveys are conducted on their website, where only their existing customers are randomly selected to participate.

As a consequence, the results are skewed, as satisfied customers are more likely to take the survey, while dissatisfied customers may not have the same opportunity. Furthermore, these surveys often lack detailed questions that allow customers to express negative opinions.

Therefore, the customer satisfaction ratings presented by Mirage Insurance may not accurately represent the true satisfaction levels of their customers.

Case Study 3: Evergreen Insurance

Evergreen Insurance understands the importance of customer satisfaction and utilizes unbiased sources to assess their performance. They participate in surveys conducted by renowned organizations such as J.D. Power and Associates.

These surveys involve a diverse sample of customers, and specific criteria are considered, such as age, gender, and location. The results are then published independently, ensuring the transparency and reliability of the ratings.

Evergreen Insurance’s commitment to providing exceptional customer service and their consistently high ratings in these surveys make them a popular choice among potential car insurance customers.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are customer satisfaction ratings in the context of car insurance companies?

Customer satisfaction ratings refer to the feedback and opinions provided by customers regarding their experience with a particular car insurance company. These ratings typically measure various aspects such as customer service, claims handling, policy offerings, affordability, and overall satisfaction.

Why are customer satisfaction ratings important for car insurance companies?

Customer satisfaction ratings are crucial for car insurance companies for several reasons:

Reputation: High customer satisfaction ratings enhance the reputation of the insurance company and build trust among potential customers.
Customer Retention: Satisfied customers are more likely to renew their policies with the same insurer, leading to increased customer retention.
Attracting New Customers: Positive ratings and reviews can attract new customers who consider customer satisfaction as an important factor when choosing an insurance provider.
Competitive Advantage: Companies with higher satisfaction ratings may gain a competitive edge over their rivals.

How are customer satisfaction ratings determined for car insurance companies?

Customer satisfaction ratings can be determined through various methods, including:

Surveys: Insurance companies often conduct surveys to gather feedback from their customers, assessing their satisfaction levels and experiences.
Independent Ratings Agencies: Organizations like J.D. Power and Consumer Reports conduct independent studies and surveys to evaluate and rank insurance companies based on customer satisfaction.
Online Reviews: Customers can leave reviews on various platforms, such as social media, review websites, and online forums, which can contribute to the overall perception of an insurance company’s customer satisfaction.

Are there any specific rating agencies that assess customer satisfaction in the car insurance industry?

Yes, several independent rating agencies assess customer satisfaction in the car insurance industry. Some well-known agencies include:

J.D. Power: They conduct surveys and provide ratings on various aspects of customer satisfaction in the insurance industry, including auto insurance.
Consumer Reports: This organization collects data from policyholders and rates insurance companies based on customer satisfaction and other criteria.
AM Best: While primarily focused on financial strength ratings, AM Best also considers customer satisfaction as a factor in evaluating insurance companies.